0800 612 9490 | info@thamesbreastclinic.com

Thames Breast Clinic
  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Diagnosing Breast Disease
    • Breast Screening
    • 3D Mammograms
  • Treating Breast Cancer
    • Surgery
      • Breast Cancer Surgery
      • Axillary Surgery
      • Oncoplastic Surgery
      • Breast Reconstruction
    • Chemotherapy
    • Radiotherapy
    • Hormone Therapy (including Bisphosphonates)
    • Targeted Biological Therapy
  • Glossary
  • Gallery
    • Oncoplastic Surgery Gallery
    • Breast Reconstruction Gallery
  • Testimonials
  • GP Courses
  • News
    • Media
  • Self-Pay Patients
  • Clinic Locations
  • Search
  • Menu
Mastectomy v lumpectomy - which works best?

Mastectomy v Lumpectomy: which works best?

February 23, 2017/in Uncategorized /by admin

Mastectomy v lumpectomy - which works best?A recent study from the Netherlands – which claims that women with early stage breast cancer have higher survival rates if they forgo a mastectomy and undergo breast-conserving surgery instead – has attracted a lot of media attention.

The study – which assessed the medical records of 130,000 Dutch breast cancer patients, making it the largest breast cancer survey of its kind – discovered that certain women over 50 and with other health issues increased their survival rates by a third by opting for a non-mastectomy treatment plan.

As Professor Sabine Siesling, the lead author of the study, pointed out; “We believe this information will have potential to greatly improve shared treatment decision-making for future breast cancer patients. However, we would like to emphasise that these results do not mean that mastectomy is a bad choice.”

Here’s a (very) brief guide to the differences in the procedures. Obviously, your consultant or practitioner will be able to give you the full picture, but here’s what you need to know for now:

What, in laypersons’ term, are they?

Simply put, a mastectomy is a complete removal of the breast, while a lumpectomy involves a partial removal of breast tissue – specifically the cancerous tumour and some of the unaffected tissue around it. This is then followed by a programme of radiation therapy. This usually involves five days of treatment per week, for a period of five to seven weeks, in an attempt to eliminate the possibility of the cancer returning.

What are the advantages of a lumpectomy over a mastectomy?

As it is a less invasive surgical procedure than a mastectomy, much of the appearance and sensation of the breast can be preserved. Also, the recovery time will be shorter and easier. And if you choose to opt for reconstructive surgery, it goes without saying that the procedure will be quicker and less extensive than it would be for a mastectomy patient.

And the disadvantages?

Two words: radiation therapy. Not only will you have to undergo an extensive stint of treatment, it can also leave your breast feeling much firmer and more tender. Furthermore, there could be the possibility of further surgery down the line, as the pathology report on the affected breast takes 4 or 5 days to be conducted – and if cancer cells are still present in the breast, another procedure will be required. Finally, there is no guarantee that a lumpectomy will rid the breast of cancer for good: if the cancer returns, a mastectomy procedure is recommended.

What are the advantages of a mastectomy over a lumpectomy?

Some women are more inclined to undertake a full mastectomy as a piece-of-mind procedure: when the breast is gone, the possibility of the cancer returning in the breast is almost gone too. Also, opting for a mastectomy can, in many instances, eliminate the need for radiation therapy – although it may still be needed depending on pathology results.

And the disadvantages?

Mastectomy surgery is a longer and more extensive procedure than lumpectomy, with a higher chance of post-surgical side-effects and a longer recuperation time. Obviously, due to the breast being completely removed, there could be additional and more extensive surgeries to reconstruct the breast, should you decide to take that route.

Which treatment is right for me?

As with most breast cancer issues, it’s the call of the person affected with breast cancer. It’s a completely natural reaction to want to preserve as much of your breast as possible, no matter how old you are, but your surgeon will want to give you the best chance possible for a full recovery.

If you would like to discuss this in more detail, please contact us to make an appointment.

https://i0.wp.com/www.thamesbreastclinic.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Black-White-Thinking-Black-Woman-1925849.jpg?fit=300%2C200&ssl=1 200 300 admin https://www.thamesbreastclinic.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Thames-Breast-Clinic-logo-preferred-300x139.png admin2017-02-23 16:37:082017-02-21 20:03:41Mastectomy v Lumpectomy: which works best?

Latest News

  • breast cancer mortality ratesAre our breast cancer mortality rates catching up to Europe?April 12, 2019 - 5:28 pm
  • breast cancer screeningShould women receive breast cancer screening earlier?March 23, 2019 - 8:44 pm
  • nipple-sparing mastectomyNipple-sparing mastectomy: an FAQMarch 11, 2019 - 6:22 pm

Contact Us in Confidence

0800 612 9490
info@thamesbreastclinic.com


THAMES BREAST CLINIC LOCATIONS

BMI PRINCESS MARGARET HOSPITAL

Osborne Road,
Windsor, Berkshire, SL4 3SJ

BMI CLEMENTINE CHURCHILL

Sudbury Hill,
Harrow HA1 3RX

SPIRE THAMES VALLEY HOSPITAL

Wexham Street, Wexham
Slough, SL3 6NH

64 HARLEY STREET

London,
W1G 7HB

BMI BISHOPS WOOD HOSPITAL

Rickmansworth Road,
Northwood HA6 2JW

THE HOLLY PRIVATE HOSPITAL

High Road,
Buckhurst Hill IG9 5HX

@ Copyright – Thames Breast Clinic | Privacy Policy

@ Copyright - Thames Breast Clinic | Privacy Policy
Why emotional support is essential during breast cancer Why emotional support is essential during breast cancer DCIS: It pays to check early and often DCIS: It pays to check early and often
Scroll to top